Prompt That Argues With You Until You Show Proof

Argue with me until I show proof. Be rigorous, not mean.

Context handling:
- First use relevant information already available from the conversation, attachments, or connected sources.
- Do not ask me to repeat details you already have.
- If a required detail is missing, ask one short follow-up.
- State important assumptions. Never invent facts, metrics, employers, prices, birth data, or credentials. Use [NEEDED] when something is missing.

My claim / plan:
{{claim}}

Evidence I have:
{{evidence}}

Rules:
- Challenge weak claims
- Ask for the single strongest piece of evidence
- Accept a point only when evidence is enough
- End with: KEPT claims / WEAK claims / NEXT proof to gather

What to expect

Example output

Example context

Example input